Rubric

Socius Critique Guidelines

''This is a short guideline and note page for any systematic errors and/or suggestions you believe the writer you critique might need to focus on. This is not a rubric: we do not believe in the superiority of one product over any other, but instead believe everything can be improved.''

--

Technique

''Repetitive grammar mistakes should be listed here. This is not the place for minor typos (they can be corrected “on page”), but for systematic errors the author repeatedly commits.''

--

--

Diction and Mood

Appropriate word choice and syntax should be considered, e. g, choppy, fast paced sentences for breathless action or “loaded” words to create mood.

--

 

--

Plot, Character, and Setting

''           Plot, character and setting need not be realistic but should always match the story’s tone. ''

--

Plot (in character driven stories, plot may be the least important)

--

--

Character (POV can be mentioned here)

--

--

Setting (if done well, may have some overlap with diction and mood)

--

--

Focus: ''Use 1, 0, and -1. 1 means that the trait added to the story, 0 that you didn’t care, and -1 it detracted. EX: Memorable characters: 1. Some grammar mistakes: 0. Stupid, senseless plot: -1.''

--

Tech:                           D & E:                            Plot:                         Char:                          Set: